The Oak Island Compendium
On this letter, Thompson mentions seeing Mr. Creighton. This was undoubtedly Augustus Oliver Creighton (generally known as A. O. Creighton), who owned the Bookbindery (along with his brother Herbert) through which the ninety Foot Stone was mentioned to have been placed on public show.
So right here we’ve Jotham (J. B.) McCully, the man who gave us the earliest mention (1862)of the inscribed stone taken out of the money Pit in 1803 or 1804, and A. O. Creighton, the man in whose window the stone was mentioned to be displayed, talked about in the identical letter. Each these males have been members of the corporate attempting to get well the treasure on Oak Island at that period in time.
It is the second paragraph which grabs our attention. It is being instructed that “a piece of the stone” be despatched to a lady in Boston. What stone Why ship a bit of it After all, the quick conclusion to leap to is that it’s the 90 Foot Stone. Both McCully and Creighton were involved in removing the stone from John Smith’s fireplace in his former farmhouse on Oak Island. The answer as to why could simply be thought to be as a result of the ninety Foot Stone was mentioned to be a kind of stone not native to Stone Island Outlet Nova Scotia. Maybe they needed to consult a lady who was knowledgeable in stones, who might determine the place of origin of the stone itself. Perhaps it was a bigger piece of the ninety Foot Stone, with a number of the symbols on it Perhaps they needed to seek the advice of a linguistics professional This does not seem like the prudent method to have someone assess the symbols carved on the stone though. Sending a photograph or a tracing, and even an illustration of the symbols on the stone can be bodily simpler and extra economical. Then we should consider the accepted timeline for the events surrounding the stone. The stone was mentioned in the three part article telling the history of the Oak Island Treasure Hunt, which was printed in late 1863, with half three of the sequence printed in very early 1864. It acknowledged, partly:
“…a flag stone about two ft lengthy and one large, with numerous rudely lower letters and figures upon it. They were in hopes the inscription would throw some invaluable mild on their search, however sadly they couldn’t decipher it, because it was both too badly minimize or didn’t look like in their own vernacular.” – Source: 1864 January 2 – The Colonist, Tri-weekly Edition, Halifax N.S. (Newspaper)
On January 2nd of 1864, John Hunter-Duvar, secretary of the Historical Society of Nova Scotia, reads this text, and instantly writes to George Cooke, a member of the present treasure hunters on Oak Island, asking to study who at the moment possesses the 90ft Stone.
“Sir, An attention-grabbing sketch of the Oak stone island jumper kids Island enterprise appears in the “Colonist” newspaper of this morning, and of which I believe you’re the writer. You point out a flagstone bearing an inscription was discovered and because it was preserved within the household of Mr. Smith ‘it could also be seen by the curious at the current day.’ Could I beg, within the identify of the society, to be favored with the identify of the individual in whose possession the stone is, as, if genuine, it can not fail to be vital as a historic object. I’ve the honor to be Sir, Your most obedient servant J. Hunter Duvar Corr. Sec.” – Supply: 1864 January 2 – Letter written by John Hunter Duvar to George Cooke
On January 27th of 1864, George Cooke replies to Hunter-Duvar’s inquiry.
“On my return I discovered your letter of the 2nd on the spot, desiring data respecting the flag-stone bearing an inscription taken out of the Outdated Pit on Oak Island, awaiting me… The stone in question was saved by Mr. Smith, who owned the place. About forty years in the past, at a time when nothing was doing on the island & when the prospects of the treasure seekers appeared altogether hopeless. Mr. Smith built, what was then called, his new house. In building it, he found that this attention-grabbing stone would go well with admirably a nook within the again a part of his chimney, and as he started to think about it of no worth to himself or to anybody else, on account of the operations at the island having ceased, he unfortunately put it into the chimney, the flat aspect out. Fourteen years ago Mr. Smith pointed out the stone, then & I imagine nonetheless within the chimney, and assured me that it was the equivalent stone taken out of the “Money Pit” on the Island, in his presence. Mr. Smith has since died & the property has passed into other arms. Mr. Graves now owns the property & building is occupied by the present Oak Island Association. I am not aware whether or not Mr. Graves is aware of something in regards to the stone being within the Chimney. On making inquiries since receipt of you letter, I discover that the chimney has been boxed spherical by a wooden partition, and that a flight of stairs goes up near where the stone is inserted. I was not aware of this earlier than. This may occasionally stop the stone from being obtained at with out bother, and maybe, expense, however because it is essential for the interests of the “Oak Island Association” if for no other object that the inscription on the stone must be deciphered, its place in the chimney ought to not ___ be an insuperable barrier to the try to decipher it being made. On the time I noticed the stone I observed that there have been some rudely minimize letters, figures or characters upon it. I can not recollect which, but they seem as if that they had been scraped out by a blunt instrument, quite than minimize with a pointy one.